How to Start a Difficult Conversation with Dialogue

Difficult conversations can be, well… difficult. Whether you're addressing a workplace conflict, talking to a friend about money, or giving feedback to a colleague, knowing how to start the conversation makes a huge difference. Effective communication is an essential skill in both personal and professional settings, and mastering it can improve relationships, enhance leadership skills, and boost confidence.

If you want better results from your crucial conversations, follow these three steps in the first 30 seconds:

• State the facts
• Share why those facts are a concern
• End with a question that invites the other person into open dialogue

The goal is to speak up in a way that encourages someone to share their perspective. And what’s the best way to get their perspective? Ask them.

The Power of Effective Communication in Difficult Conversations

Recently, I had a tough conversation with a family member about their spending habits. I was worried about their financial future, and I had tried multiple times to change their behaviour. But my efforts were ineffective—until I used a simple question that transformed our communication.

Before, my advice had been met with resistance. But when I followed a structured approach, stating the facts, sharing my concerns, and then asking "What’s your perspective?"...everything changed. We shifted from confrontation to collaboration.

This question is powerful because it invites dialogue rather than defensiveness. Asking for someone’s perspective shows confidence in your reason for opening the conversation and humility in acknowledging that you don’t have all the answers.

If you want to improve your approach to handling tough conversations, here are three key strategies to enhance your communication skills.

1. Don’t Treat This as a Problem-Solving Session

One common mistake is trying to solve the perceived problem too soon. Difficult conversations aren’t about jumping to solutions; they’re about understanding perspectives.

Avoid following up "What’s your perspective?" with problem-solving questions like:

• "How are you going to fix this?"
• "What are we going to do to solve this problem?"
• "How will you make sure this never happens again?"

These types of questions imply judgment and shut down communication. If you want to be an effective communicator, focus on seeing the full picture before attempting to resolve anything. You don’t want to fix the wrong problem, or worse, assume there’s a problem when there isn’t one.

This approach is fundamental in leadership skills and communication training, which many professionals refine through communication skills courses, such as Crucial Conversations for Mastering Dialogue.

2. Use Open-Ended Questions to Encourage Dialogue

It’s easy to fall into the habit of asking yes/no questions, such as "You agree with that, right?" or "You’re not going to do that again, right?" However, these don’t invite meaningful conversation. They limit responses and reduce the opportunity for real insight.

Instead, try these open-ended alternatives:

• "Can you help me understand your perspective on this?"
• "What led you to that decision?"
• "Can you walk me through your thought process?"

By asking open-ended questions, you encourage the other person to share their thoughts, leading to a more productive and engaging conversation. This technique is commonly taught in communication workshops to help professionals improve their workplace communication and leadership skills.

3. Ensure Your Questions Are Non-Judgmental

No one likes to feel judged, and even well-meaning questions can sometimes come across as accusatory.

Consider these two different ways of asking the same question:

• Judgmental: "Why did you do that?"
• Non-Judgmental: "Can you help me understand your reasoning?"

The first question implies wrongdoing, putting the person on the defensive. The second, however, is more neutral and invites an explanation.

A Workplace Example of Non-Judgmental Questions

In a communication training session I led, a group of nurses shared their experience with doctors who, when discussing patient care, would ask, "Why did you do that?" This question made them feel defensive and hesitant to speak up.

A better way to approach the situation would be:

• "I noticed something and wanted to understand your perspective. Can you walk me through your thought process?"
• "I don’t want to make assumptions, so I wanted to check in with you first. What’s your perspective on what happened?"

By changing the phrasing, you shift from blame to curiosity, which is a crucial skill in business communication.

The Benefits of Mastering Difficult Conversations

When you approach tough conversations with open dialogue, you experience several benefits:

1. Stronger Professional Relationships: Good workplace communication fosters trust and collaboration.
2. More Effective Conflict Resolution: Leaders who communicate well can address issues before they escalate.
3. Greater Confidence in Conversations: Whether at work or in personal life, mastering difficult conversations makes them less intimidating.

Improved Leadership Skills: Strong communicators inspire and lead teams effectively.

Putting It All Together

Starting a difficult conversation doesn’t have to be overwhelming. By using these three key steps, you’ll foster better communication, stronger relationships, and more productive discussions:

1. State the facts in a neutral and clear manner.
2. Share your concerns without making assumptions.
3. Ask open-ended, non-judgmental questions to invite dialogue.

‍

To learn more about how your organisation can benefit from Crucial Conversations for Mastering Dialogue training, click here.  

If you want to learn more about Crucial Learning skills, subscribe to our newsletter.